Navy use Adams Simulations to Validate Designs for Ships' Hull and Deck Machinery
Engineers at the Naval Surface Warfare Center use ADAMS simulations to conceptualize and validate their designs for ships' hull and deck machinery. This has helped them slash equipment design cycles by 50% and more.
Hull and Deck Machinery equipment is an integral part of a US Navy ship mission. This equipment includes items such as powered and watertight closures, cargo/weapons elevators, embarkation equipment, cranes, boat handling equipment, and habitability. Whether moving ammunition or providing helicopter access, these systems must be fully operational when called upon. In addition, they must be safe to operate, maintainable by the ship crew, and affordable to the Navy throughout the equipment lifecycle.
Hull and Deck Machinery Equipment is a responsibility of the Naval Surface Warfare Center, Carderock Division (NSWCCD) in Philadelphia, PA. NSWCCD is an engineering field activity under the Naval Sea Systems Command (NAVSEA). In this capacity, they provide research and development, test and evaluation, fleet support, and in-service engineering for surface and undersea vehicle hull, mechanical, and electrical (HM&E) systems and propulsors. In addition to the U.S. Navy, support is also provided to the Maritime Administration and maritime industry.
Ralph Tursi, mechanical engineer, supervises the Mechanical Computer- Aided Engineering (MCAE) section of the NSWCCD Hull and Deck Machinery Department. His team plays a vital role in the design of this equipment for new construction ships, as well as design improvements for in-service craft. In this role, Tursi and his team are faced with several engineering challenges. Says Tursi, "First, we must take into account that the shipboard environment is typically harsh and promotes corrosion. As a result, we must ensure that shipboard designs are reliable and able to withstand the unique elements encountered onboard ship."
Other important design considerations exist for Navy shipboard equipment. Tursi explains, "In today's 21st century Navy, our ships feature an elite, highly trained, professional crew. These crews must rely on extensive automation. The ship and crew need to focus on the mission at hand, with less time available to devote to equipment maintenance. In addition, the demographics of the typical Navy crew have changed, with significantly more women than in the past. As a result, habitability design specifications must also accommodate the female population. We have to incorporate these human factors into our designs."
Since ships are fighting machines, the equipment must withstand military requirements. Tursi adds, "This is an important distinction between Navy and commercial vessels. The commercial industry is certainly driving many of the latest technological innovations. As a result, the Navy typically looks to industry for technologically advanced products and equipment. However, these products in many cases require modifications to withstand military requirements. This issue can make designing our equipment very challenging."
The U.S. Navy is just as demanding as any civilian or commercial customer. Says Tursi, "It is imperative that shipboard equipment be safe, reliable, and affordable throughout the life of the ship. Our primary mission as a NAVSEA activity is to support the Naval fleet. If we can't accomplish this, the Navy will find someone else who can."
Tursi and his team extensively utilize MCAE software to help them meet their objectives and customer expectations. "We use a variety of MCAE tools, such as 3D modeling, finite element analysis, and mechanical system simulation software. Mechanical system simulation software is probably one of our most important MCAE tools," says Tursi, "and for this we utilize the ADAMS product from Mechanical Dynamics, Inc. [Ann Arbor, MI]."
The Benefits of ADAMS
As a conceptualization tool, ADAMS assists Tursi and his team in creating and visualizing new ideas. ýWorking with ADAMS is a much more productive use of our time than trying to draw manually or with a 2D system. ADAMS enables us to conceptualize a design quickly. The software has been a real winner with that aspect of the design cycle. For us to be able to show a nontechnical person not only what our designs will look like, but how they will perform, is very important. The technology helps our customer better understand the equipment and designs that we will provide."
Tursi likes the ability to expand ADAMS models. "We can transform our conceptual designs into real engineering models. That process eliminates a lot of rework and time. We can quickly move from concepts to working models with real engineering information. The software facilitates engineering efficiency and productivity. As a result, we have reduced our design cycles by at least 50 percent."
Prior to implementing ADAMS, the team addressed new product designs manually. "We would typically develop 2D CAD sketches. Even when we migrated to 3D software to develop new designs," he says, "the process remained difficult because of the number of configurations we needed to show our customer. The 3D models were simply still shots. However, with ADAMS as part of our toolkit, we now have the ability to show real-world equipment simulations. In addition, we are now armed with the powerful flexibility to change design configurations on the fly. We and our customers are very confident that we can develop and optimize the best possible designs."
After implementing ADAMS for several projects, Tursi says the Navy realized the difference in his departmentýs ability to address new product design requirements in a much more expedient manner. "We are able to show and convince our customers that we are performing tasks much faster and more easily as a result of using ADAMS. Our sponsors need to see computer-based 3D models, especially since entire ships are developed using 3D modeling software. Making full use of our CAD/CAE tools throughout the design process demonstrates our commitment to using cutting edge technology to develop the best equipment for the Navy."
"Time to market is just as important to the Navy as it is to commercial manufacturers," says Tursi. "For the closure safety project [see sidebar at right], we recognized real time-savings benefits using ADAMS. We were able to demonstrate a viable design solution while avoiding multiple purchases or lengthy in-house testing. ADAMS helped minimize these steps and helped to eliminate the cycle of continuous re-design and re-testing.
"As the U.S. Navy moves toward an automated, state-of-the-art fleet, it's imperative that we take advantage of cutting-edge software such as ADAMS," continues Tursi. "ADAMS is another tool to ensure that the equipment we design will fit and function as required. We have competition just like any other business. We know that MCAE solutions such as ADAMS will help us remain successful and competitive."
Naval Surface Warfare Center
Carderock Division, Philadelphia, PA